One Sings, the Other Doesnโt: Reprise
Agnรจs Vardaโs 1977 feminist classic One Sings, the Other Doesnโt (L'Une chante, l'autre pas) captured the spirit of the womenโs liberation movement through the enduring friendship of Pauline and Suzanne. More than four decades later, a fictional sequel titled One Sings, the Other Doesnโt: Reprise imagines their legacy continued through a new generationโan emotionally rich and politically charged journey that bridges past and present.
Set in the early 2020s, Reprise follows the daughters of Pauline and SuzanneโClara and Lilaโnow women in their thirties, navigating a complex landscape of modern feminism, climate anxiety, and identity politics. The film opens with the death of Suzanne, prompting a reunion between Clara, an eco-activist filmmaker, and Lila, a corporate lawyer disillusioned by the system. As they revisit their mothersโ letters and recordings, the film becomes a meditation on memory, generational trauma, and the evolution of feminist thought.
What stands out most in this imagined continuation is the way it mirrors Vardaโs original tone: intimate, poetic, yet boldly political. The sequel does not try to replicate the 1970s but instead honors its emotional truth by showing how the personal remains deeply political. The women's experiencesโbalancing motherhood, career, and activismโecho Pauline and Suzanneโs paths, but in a world now shaped by digital surveillance, social media activism, and renewed threats to bodily autonomy.
Visually, Reprise leans into a hybrid of documentary and fiction, much like Vardaโs style, weaving archival footage of womenโs marches from the '70s into present-day protests. Music once again plays a central role, this time through Claraโs protest songs, a subtle homage to Paulineโs earlier performances.
While the film occasionally veers into idealism, it is grounded by moments of tensionโbetween the protagonists, within the feminist movement, and in their personal choices. It asks hard questions: What does solidarity mean across generations? Is the movement progressing, or repeating itself?
Ultimately, One Sings, the Other Doesnโt: Reprise is a heartfelt tribute to female resilience and intergenerational bonds. Itโs a fictional sequel we wish were realโoffering a tender, honest look at how two women's voices can echo far beyond their time.