Eye for an Eye (2025): A Dreamlike Descent into Horror
Eye for an Eye is a 2025 American horror thriller that marks the feature directorial debut of Colin Tilley, a filmmaker best known for his work in music videos. Written by Elisa Victoria and Michael Tully, the film stars Whitney Peak as Anna, with S. Epatha Merkerson, Golda Rosheuvel, Finn Bennett, and Laken Giles in supporting roles.
The story centers around Anna, a teenager who relocates to Florida following the tragic death of her parents. She moves in with her grandmother, May, and attempts to find her footing in a new environment. Seeking acceptance among her peers, Anna begins to mix with a dangerous crowd. One night, she witnesses a shocking act of violence, which sets off a terrifying series of supernatural events. A mysterious entity known only as "Mr. Sandman" begins haunting her dreams — a malevolent force that punishes bullies and preys on fear, stealing the eyes of its victims as they sleep.
The film draws heavily on psychological horror and dream logic, blending surreal sequences with real-world trauma. It explores themes of grief, peer pressure, and justice, all wrapped in a Southern Gothic atmosphere. Though set in Florida, the movie was filmed in Savannah, Georgia, which provides a visually haunting backdrop of moss-draped trees and decaying beauty that enhances the mood of the film.
Director Colin Tilley brings a fresh visual style to the genre, using his background in music videos to create vivid, unsettling imagery. The cinematography by Robert Leitzell is striking, filled with dreamlike color palettes and shadowy corners that suggest terror lurking just beneath the surface. The score, composed by Timothy Williams, deepens the sense of dread with a haunting mix of ambient tones and sudden musical stingers.
Whitney Peak delivers a powerful performance as Anna, capturing both vulnerability and quiet strength as she navigates her trauma and faces her nightmarish stalker. S. Epatha Merkerson adds emotional depth as her grandmother, grounding the film with a sense of generational resilience and family legacy.
Released in June 2025 by Vertical Entertainment, Eye for an Eye had a limited theatrical release alongside a video-on-demand rollout. Critics praised the film’s unique aesthetic, intense performances, and its balance of supernatural horror with coming-of-age drama. The film was especially noted for its atmospheric storytelling and its ability to build suspense without relying solely on jump scares.
In summary, Eye for an Eye is a fresh and chilling entry into modern horror. It combines visual artistry with emotional storytelling, anchored by strong performances and a compelling supernatural mystery. For fans of horror that lingers in the subconscious, this film is both disturbing and thought-provoking — a stylish reminder that sometimes, vengeance can take on a life of its own, especially in the world of dreams.
-1751863435-q80.webp "STAY SAFE")
